The Case for High-Quality SARS-CoV-2 Antibody Testing

Commercial tests for a second wave of COVID-19 testing may call for greater sensitivity and specificity than what is currently available. Find out why.
The Case for High-Quality SARS-CoV-2 Antibody Testing

Despite positive news in recent days about serology tests, experts on testing warn that these tests come with big logistical and scientific challenges just as big as mass deployment of blood-based testing will require many millions of accurate tests, a system to take reliable samples, and a slew of decisions that may have to be made based on incomplete knowledge2.

According to Peter Collignon, a physician and laboratory microbiologist at Australian National University in Canberra, a high-quality test should achieve 99% or more sensitivity and specificity3.

What are sensitivity and specificity?

Sensitivity and specificity reflect the accuracy of a test relative to a reference standard. Test sensitivity is the ability of a test to correctly identify those with the disease (true positive rate), whereas test specificity is the ability of the test to correctly identify those without the disease (true negative rate).

This means that COVID-19 test sensitivity is the ability to detect SARS-CoV-2 antibodies in patients who have antibodies; COVID-19 test specificity is the ability of the test to correctly identify those who do not have antibodies.

Why sensitivity and specificity matter for COVID-19

Imagine an average U.S. city. Based on census data, the population of such city is approximately 150,000 people. Imagine that COVID-19 has infected, symptomatically and asymptomatically, 15% of that population.

This means that 22,500 people in the town have been infected, either symptomatically or asymptomatically (150,000 x 15%). With a test with 90% sensitivity, 20,250 of the 22,500 people would be correctly told they have antibodies to the virus (22,500 x 90%). But 2,250 people who have the antibodies would be told (incorrectly) they do not and that they cannot return to work.

Conversely, 127,500 people were not exposed to the virus and should not return to work. However, with a specificity of 90%, 12,750 of them will be told they have antibodies for COVID-19 but do not (127,500 x 10%, which is the false positive rate). These people will be told they can go back to work and thus become a danger to themselves and others.

False positives might lead somebody to believe that they are immune when they are not, and therefore there are significant risks in interpreting the results of these serology tests. 1
Timothy Stenzel
Director, Office of In Vitro Diagnostics and Radiological Health
U.S. Food and Drug Administration

The perils of false positives

False positives can lead to assumptions that patients have developed some immunity, when in fact they have not, leaving them and others vulnerable now and in the event of a second wave of the COVID-19 pandemic. The need for a high-quality test, one with 99% sensitivity and specificity reduces the risk of false positives as such testing will turn up only about one false positive and one false negative for every 100 true positive and true negative results.

To quote, Peter Collignon, “we may end up doing more harm than good” with a poor-quality result.

Get the latest news from Beckman Coulter on COVID-19.

1, 2 Bonislawski, A. “False Positives Could Undermine Utility of SARS-CoV-2 Serology Testing.” 360Dx, Apr 16, 2020. Accessed on Apr 20, 2020.

Editorial Team
Editorial Team
The Beckman Coulter editorial team brings you timely news and resources focused on elevating clinical laboratory performance and advancing patient care.

Related Articles

Sepsis & the Immune System: The Connection

Sepsis & the Immune System: The Connection

The human immune system is a remarkable defense mechanism designed to protect against a multitude of threats. When this sophisticated defense system goes awry and leads to a deadly condition known as sepsis, it becomes a critical medical emergency.
Two Hearts on World Heart Day

Two Hearts on World Heart Day

As the world recognizes World Heart Day on September 29, we at Beckman Coulter are focusing on cardiac health and celebrating how awareness and access to accurate diagnostic care saved the lives of two of our team members.
What’s Hidden at the Edge?

What’s Hidden at the Edge?

What can PBS review reveal? Explore the secrets of the peripheral blood smear’s feathered edge.